Saratoga Springs is a winter wonderland for the Caprice Family during the holidays. But this year, a letter from Grandma and Grandpa Caprice draws the younger generation home early to deal with a mysterious faerie infestation. Along the way, they have some Christmas fun with laughter, love, and steamy stolen moments.

Alynia and Iowin Caprice-Tintreach, witches within their respective families, travel back in time to discover the truth behind the Headless Horseman myth. They discover that the legends are true, and Alynia, herself, is a direct descendant of the original Horseman. They also discover that the legend would not exist without their direct involvement.