CLOSE TO HIM, page 16
"Is it?" she asked, a faint, cryptic smile touching her lips. "Or is it just beginning?"
"Why did you do it?" Kari asked, cutting straight to the heart of the matter. "Tommy Begay, Samuel Whitehorse… why?"
"Adjustments," Josephine said. "Not murders. They were adjustments to an account that has been unbalanced for a very long time. Tommy Begay was an unforeseen complication. He was digging too close to David’s history, and David became… agitated. His death was a regrettable necessity to keep David focused on the primary objective."
She spoke of Tommy’s murder with the detached regret of a gardener pulling a weed. The coldness of it was more shocking than any screamed confession.
"And Samuel Whitehorse?" Ben asked.
"Samuel was a loose thread. He carried his guilt like a wet blanket, suffocating him. He was on the verge of confessing to the wrong people, for the wrong reasons. His death was a mercy. And it provided a useful tool for David to test his resolve."
"You recruited him," Kari said, watching the woman’s face for any flicker of emotion. There was none. "You found a grieving, angry young man and twisted his pain into your weapon."
"Twisted?" Josephine’s smile faded, replaced by the first spark of heat. "I gave his pain purpose. I gave him the truth. I found him fifteen years ago, working dead-end construction jobs in Phoenix, drinking himself to death. He was haunted by a mother he never knew and a failure he couldn't name. I gave him the names. I showed him the files."
She gestured to the corner of the room, where dozens of neatly labeled banker’s boxes were stacked from the floor to the ceiling. It was an archive of horror.
"I was the head nurse’s assistant at Riverside," she said, her voice taking on a new, stronger cadence, the voice of a lecturer. "I saw everything. Dr. Loomis would drunkenly botch procedures, and I would clean up the blood. Howard Brennan would deliver his ‘discipline,’ and I would stitch the children’s wounds. Samuel Whitehorse would drag runaways back, their bodies broken, and I would fill out the incident reports, using the words they gave me—‘resisted assistance,’ ‘accidental fall.’ I typed every lie. I filed every false report. I touched every piece of their corruption."
She leaned forward, her eyes bright with a fanatical light. "But every night, I went home and I wrote it all down. The real story. The name of every child, the nature of every injury, the name of every perpetrator. I kept copies of everything I could. I called it my Book of Debts. For fifty years, I have been its keeper."
"You could have gone to the police," Yazzie said, his voice tight with controlled anger. "To the FBI. At any time."
Josephine laughed, a sound like dry paper tearing. "The police? The FBI? They were part of the system! They investigated themselves and found no wrongdoing. No, Captain. The system that created the debt could not be trusted to collect it. A different kind of payment was required. A balance."
"So you sent David to do your dirty work," Kari said.
"David is not my servant," Josephine said, a hint of pride in her voice. "He is my partner. My agent of correction. His personal trauma, his guilt over failing to save Owen Peshlakai, made him the perfect instrument. His pain was the fuel, but my knowledge was the map. I taught him, trained him. How to move without being seen. How to acquire information. How to be a ghost. The locksmith trade was my idea. The perfect cover. Whoever questions the locksmith?"
"You killed Agnes Littlefeather," Kari said, the words an accusation. "David tried to stop you."
For the first time, a shadow crossed Josephine’s face. "Agnes was a disappointment. She was a witness, like me. She saw what happened. But where I chose to build a weapon from my knowledge, she chose to hide in fear. Her silence was a betrayal of every child who suffered. David, in his sentimentality, couldn't see that. He still saw her as a victim. I saw her as a collaborator. Her debt had to be paid." She smoothed a crease in her dress. "It was necessary to remind David of the purity of our mission. Emotion has no place in the balancing of accounts."
The sheer, monstrous arrogance of the woman was suffocating. She had appointed herself judge, jury, and executioner, all from the comfort of her pristine living room.
"It’s over, Josephine," Kari repeated. "We have your confession. We know where David is taking Brennan."
Josephine’s faint smile returned. "You have a piece of the story, Detective. But you are, as always, one step behind." She gestured to a single, sealed manila envelope on the coffee table. "The final act does not depend on David’s success. It does not depend on my freedom. It is already in motion."
Yazzie picked up the envelope. It was addressed to a national wire service, with prepaid overnight postage.
"My life’s work," Josephine said. "A full manifesto, detailing the systemic abuse at Riverside. It is accompanied by copies of everything. Every secret medical report, every falsified document, every confession I’ve collected. Including the video Samuel Whitehorse made before his death. I sent the package two days ago. It will be delivered to their news desk in… oh, about an hour. By sunrise tomorrow, the whole world will know what happened at Riverside. The story will finally be told."
Kari felt a dizzying sense of vertigo. This whole bloody affair, the murders, the manhunt—it was all just a prelude. The real goal was exposure on a massive, national scale. They hadn't been trying to prevent a story from getting out; they had been the unwitting actors in its violent premiere.
"Why now?" Kari asked. "You've been sitting on this information for fifty years. What changed?"
Josephine's smile faltered for just a moment, replaced by something harder. "Howard Brennan was diagnosed with terminal liver cancer six months ago. His doctors gave him a year at most. I know because I still have contacts at the hospital. After everything he'd done, he was going to die peacefully in his bed, never having faced justice. That was... unacceptable."
She smoothed her dress again. "The others who knew the truth were dying off naturally. Marcus Crow Dog has heart disease. Agnes was in her late sixties. Soon there would be no one left who could verify the truth. No living witnesses to corroborate the documents. The window was closing."
Her eyes gleamed with that fanatical light again. "So I activated David. Told him it was time. That if we waited any longer, they would all escape into death without consequence. The dead cannot be punished, Detective. Only the living can know shame."
Kari could only shake her head in disbelief and disgust.
"It doesn’t matter if you stop David," Josephine continued, her voice serene. "It doesn’t matter that you’ve found me. The balance will be achieved. The truth will be known. That is all that has ever mattered."
Kari looked at this small, quiet woman and saw the true face of the conspiracy. David was a storm, loud and full of fury. But Josephine was the tectonic plate that had shifted beneath him, silent, patient, and infinitely more destructive.
A terrible thought surfaced. If Josephine’s grand plan was already in motion, if the documents were already sent, then David Clah, her perfect, tormented weapon, was now just a loose end. A witness to her own direct involvement in Agnes’s murder.
"What did you give him for the ceremony?" Kari asked, her voice low and urgent. "You told him to meet you there. What were you bringing?"
Josephine’s smile was beatific, the smile of a saint contemplating her own martyrdom. She looked Kari directly in the eye, a flicker of what might have been pity in her gaze.
"David has carried so much pain for so long, Detective. Such a heavy burden of guilt." Her voice was soft, almost motherly. "I simply gave him what he needed to complete his task. A way to purify the ground. And a way to finally lay his own burden down."
The implication was as cold and sharp as a scalpel. Suicide. The final, neat tying of a loose thread.
Captain Yazzie had heard enough. He rose to his full height, his shadow falling across the small woman, but she did not flinch.
"Josephine Davis," he said, his voice stripped of all emotion, leaving only the flat authority of the law. "You are under arrest for the murder of Agnes Littlefeather and for conspiracy to commit murder. You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law."
As he continued with the Miranda warning, Josephine listened with polite attention, as if hearing the rules of a game she had already won. She offered no protest. When he finished, she simply stood, turned, and placed her small, frail hands behind her back.
The click of the handcuffs was a small, sharp sound in the quiet, sterile room.
While Yazzie was securing her, Kari was already on her radio. "Lisa, I need a forensics team at my location now. Seal the house. It’s a primary crime scene. The entire contents are evidence. There are dozens of boxes—the suspect’s personal archives. Treat them with extreme care. They’re the key to everything."
A local patrol car, summoned by Yazzie moments before they’d entered the house, pulled silently to the curb outside. Two grim-faced officers came to the door.
Yazzie handed their prisoner over. "She is not to be left alone for a second," he told the officers, his voice a low growl of warning. "She is more dangerous than any armed man you have ever arrested. Understood?"
The officers, seeing the look on their captain’s face, nodded grimly and escorted the quiet, gray-haired woman to their vehicle. Josephine didn’t look back. Her part in the story was over.
As the patrol car pulled away, Kari turned to Yazzie. "Captain, she gave him poison. Or a weapon. She’s counting on him to kill himself after he deals with Brennan. We have to move. Now."
They raced back to their own vehicle, leaving the quiet yellow house and its terrible, meticulously organized secrets behind for the forensics team to unearth. The first part of the conspiracy was over, the mastermind in custody. But the second, more violent act was still hurtling toward its conclusion in the high, lonely canyons of the Chuska Mountains.
And the clock was ticking
CHAPTER TWENTY FIVE
The words echoed in the sterile quiet of the squad car, a venomous whisper against the frantic rush of her own blood. A way to finally lay his own burden down.
Kari pressed harder on the accelerator, urging the vehicle faster down the dark, winding highway toward the Chuskas. She understood Josephine’s cold logic now. Confessing to a couple of police officers in her living room was an act of supreme ego, a monologue delivered by the playwright after the final curtain. But letting David Clah live was a risk. David was the only person who knew the truth of their partnership, the only one who could stand in a courtroom and testify to her direct manipulation, to her cold-blooded decision to murder Agnes Littlefeather over his objections.
With David gone, the only official narrative left would be the one Josephine herself had crafted and mailed to the world. It was the ultimate act of controlling the story.
"Ben, what’s your team’s ETA to the overlook?" Kari said into her radio, her voice tight.
"Fifteen minutes," he answered, his voice strained by exertion and patchy signal. "We’re in position on the north ridge. We have a visual on the site, but it’s intermittent. He’s chosen his ground well. Lots of cover."
"Do you see them?"
"Negative. No sign of Clah or Brennan. But something’s happening. There’s a fire. Small, contained. Like a ceremonial fire."
A purification. Just as Josephine had said. He was preparing the ground.
Kari pushed the car harder, the tires screaming around a sharp bend. Yazzie sat beside her, a stoic, silent mountain of his own regrets. He hadn't said a word since they left Josephine’s house, but Kari could feel the fury radiating from him—fury at Josephine, at the system that created her, and at himself for not seeing it sooner.
"It wasn't your fault, Captain," she said, needing to say it as much for herself as for him.
Yazzie said nothing. He just went on brooding.
They reached the tactical rendezvous point, a dusty pull-off a mile from the canyon rim, in record time. Ben was there, having descended from his position to meet them. His face was grim in the sweeping red and blue lights of the idling tactical vehicles.
"He’s there, Kari," he said as Kari jumped out of the car. "My spotter saw movement. He has Brennan tied to a rock outcropping at the center of the site. He’s not hurting him. He’s… talking to him."
"He’s getting his final confession," Kari said. "The one Josephine can’t fake." She looked past him, toward the dark maw of the canyon. "Can your snipers get a shot?"
Ben shook his head. "Not a clean one. Brennan is too close. And the wind is picking up, gusting through the canyon. There's too much risk." He hesitated. "Kari, Josephine armed him. We have to assume he’s prepared for a tactical assault."
"He’s not," Kari said. "He’s prepared for his own death. That’s what she gave him: a way out. She used him to get her story out, and now he’s a loose end. A witness to her murder of Agnes."
She looked from Ben to Yazzie, then to the armed, waiting officers of the tactical team. They were ready to storm the canyon, to descend with overwhelming force. But she saw the flaw in that plan with blinding clarity. Force was a language David Clah understood; it was the language that had defined his entire life.
It would only validate his worldview. It would trigger the end Josephine had planned.
She started stripping off her gear. Her tactical vest, her extra magazines, her radio. She unholstered her Glock and held it out to Ben.
"What are you doing?" he asked, his eyes wide with alarm.
"I’m not going in as a cop," she said. "I’m not going in as a weapon. He’s expecting that. I’m going in as a person. As Anna Chee’s daughter."
"Kari, that’s suicide," Yazzie said, stepping forward. "I can’t authorize that. It’s a direct violation of every protocol."
"With all due respect, sir, your protocols are the game he expects us to play. He’s not a standard suspect. He’s a man standing at the edge of a fifty-year abyss, and he’s about to jump. Shouting at him through a bullhorn isn't going to stop him."
To Kari's surprise, the captain didn't argue further. He just gazed at her, frowning.
She looked at Ben. "Give me a ten-minute head start. If I can’t talk him down, then you do what you have to do. But you have to give me that chance."
Ben looked at Yazzie, torn between his loyalty to his captain and his faith in his partner. He saw the story in her eyes, the one that had been building since she first set foot back on the reservation. This wasn't just a case for her. It was a reckoning with her own heritage, with her mother’s legacy. He took the Glock from her hand.
"Ten minutes," Yazzie said finally, his voice heavy with the weight of the decision. "Then we're coming in. Go."
Kari turned and descended into the canyon alone, the darkness swallowing her whole. She moved quickly, her feet sure on the familiar terrain. The air grew colder as she descended, carrying the scent of woodsmoke and the sharp, clean smell of high-desert sage. The wind whispered through the rock formations, sounding like voices, like ghosts.
She felt the medicine pouch beneath her shirt, a warm, solid weight against her skin. She wasn't armed, but she wasn't unprotected.
She saw the light of the fire first, a flickering orange glow against the ancient red rock. As she drew closer, she could hear his voice, a low, rhythmic chant. It wasn't a traditional Diné song; it was a litany of names, the names from the chalkboard, repeated over and over like a mantra of grief.
She stopped at the edge of the clearing. The site was a natural stone amphitheater. In the center, the fire burned brightly. Howard Brennan was tied to a large sandstone monolith, his head slumped onto his chest, his face pale and slack in the firelight. He looked like a broken effigy.
David Clah stood before the fire, his back to her. He was gaunt, his frame wiry but radiating an intensity that was almost palpable. He held the pistol he’d taken from the federal agent in one hand, but it was pointed at the ground. He was swaying, lost in his ritual.
Kari took a breath, gathering the silence of the canyon around her, and stepped into the clearing. "David," she said.
His name, spoken softly, broke the spell. He spun around with surprising speed and raised the pistol, aiming it directly at her heart. His eyes were wide and wild in the firelight, burning with a mixture of righteous fury and profound exhaustion. The scar on his wrist was a pale, crescent moon against his skin.
"You should not be here," he said. "This is sacred ground. This is between me and him. Between the past and the present."
"The past is done with him, David," Kari said, holding her hands up, open and empty, to show she was unarmed. "And Josephine is done with you."
His face contorted at the mention of her name. "She is a prophet. She kept the records. She showed me the path to balance."
"She showed you the path to her own revenge," Kari said, taking a slow step forward. "She used you, David. She used your pain, the pain of a twelve-year-old boy who tried to be a hero, and she twisted it to fit her own story. The bite mark on your wrist? The leg they broke? That’s your pain. Not hers. She doesn’t know what it’s like."
"She knows suffering!" he shouted, his voice echoing off the canyon walls. "She lost her sister!"
"And then she watched for fifty years while others suffered, and she did nothing but take notes," Kari countered, her voice rising to meet his. "She let you believe you were partners, but she killed Agnes Littlefeather against your wishes, didn't she? Because Agnes’s fear was an inconvenience to her perfect plan. She doesn’t care about balance. She cares about control."
She saw a flicker of doubt in his wild eyes. She had hit a nerve.
"Your mother wouldn’t want this, David," she said, her voice softening now. "My mother… she was looking for these same stories. She knew violence only creates more violence. It corrupts the ground it touches. This place… your mother’s place of power… you’re about to poison it with more death. Her memory doesn't deserve that."
_preview.jpg)
