CLOSE TO HIM, page 12
"Who else was involved in these cover-ups?" she pressed. "Who helped create the false records, dispose of evidence?"
"There was a whole system," Brennan said, seeming relieved to talk about structure rather than specific crimes. "Medical staff who wrote false reports. Administrative assistants who created transfer documents. Maintenance who... handled logistics."
"Names," Ben said. "We need names."
"Most are dead. Natural causes, before you ask. The few who are left..." He shrugged. "Check the personnel records. If you can find them."
"Someone found them," Kari said. "Someone accessed Samuel Whitehorse's hidden files. Someone who's been tracking survivors and staff for years."
"Then you should be looking at people with access," Brennan suggested. "Museum workers, researchers, anyone who's been digging into boarding school history."
"Like Dr. Rebecca Martinez?" Kari asked.
Brennan's expression shifted. "Michael's daughter. I heard she was trying to make amends for her father's involvement. Counseling survivors, writing papers."
"What was Michael Martinez's role exactly?"
"He identified problem students. Recommended them for special discipline. Wrote reports that justified whatever happened to them." Brennan's voice carried old resentment. "Then acted shocked when those students ended up damaged or dead."
"You didn't like him," Ben observed.
"He was a hypocrite. At least I knew what I was. Martinez pretended he was helping those kids while sending them to me for punishment."
"Who else pretended?" Kari asked. "Who else maintained a facade while participating in the abuse?"
Brennan thought for a moment. "The medical staff were the worst. Dr. Patricia Loomis. She'd patch kids up after discipline sessions, document their injuries as 'accidents' or 'self-inflicted.' Died in 2015. But she had an assistant..."
He frowned, trying to remember.
"Young woman, very quiet. Josephine something. She was maybe early twenties then, so she'd be in her sixties now. Always took notes, never said much. I remember thinking she watched everything like she was memorizing it."
"Josephine what?" Ben pressed.
"Can't remember. Started with a B? She left before the school closed. Said she couldn't stomach it anymore."
Kari made a note. Another potential witness or suspect, someone who'd seen the worst of the abuse and kept quiet. How many more were out there, carrying decades of guilt or rage?
"Mr. Brennan," she said, "in your opinion, who would have both the motive and the capability to commit these murders?"
"Anyone who lost someone," he said immediately. "Parent, sibling, child. The pain doesn't fade. It festers. Turns into something else."
"David Clah," Kari said.
"Never really knew him—kept to himself, even before what happened with his mother. He was raised by relatives after Sarah died. But I heard about him later, when he showed up at that support group. Samuel mentioned him. Said the boy had his mother's eyes. Same intensity. Same refusal to let things go."
"When did Samuel mention this?"
"Years ago. We'd meet sometimes. Not friends, exactly, but bound by shared secrets. He said David asked questions about his mother, about what really happened. Samuel told him the official story, but..."
"But David didn't believe it," Ben finished.
"Would you?" Brennan asked. "Your mother dies at a school that's known for mysterious deaths, and you're supposed to accept it was suicide?"
"Is David capable of murder?" Kari asked directly.
Brennan met her eyes. "Anyone's capable of murder, Detective. Put them under enough pressure, take away enough hope, let the pain build long enough. The only question is what finally triggers it."
"What triggered you?" Ben asked quietly.
Brennan's face shut down. "Lawyer," he said. "I'm done talking."
But he'd already told them more than he realized. The picture was becoming clearer—a system of abuse and cover-ups that created countless victims, any of whom might have decided that legal justice would never come. Someone who'd waited, planned, gathered evidence, and finally acted.
"One more question," Kari said as they prepared to end the interview. "The person who left you gifts. You said they walked toward the hiking trail. Which trail specifically?"
Brennan hesitated, then seemed to decide this was harmless information. "The one that leads up to the old fire tower. Windy Ridge Trail."
Kari knew that trail. It led to an abandoned forest service tower with views of the entire valley. A perfect place to watch, to plan, to hide.
"Thank you, Mr. Brennan. We'll get you that lawyer."
As they left the interview room, Ben pulled Kari aside. "Josephine B. Another lead to chase."
"And the trail," Kari added. "If the killer's been using that area..."
"They might have left evidence. Or might still be using it."
Kari's phone buzzed. Lisa Becenti, texting from the lab: "Found something in Agnes's day planner. The 'D' she was planning to call wasn't David. Full entry says 'Call D. Benally about documents.' Checking records now."
D. Benally. Not David Clah, but another D entirely.
The case kept sprouting new branches just when Kari thought she was close to the trunk. But somewhere in this tangle of names and connections was their killer.
She just had to follow the right thread
CHAPTER EIGHTEEN
The predawn chill of the police station was a familiar purgatory, smelling of burnt coffee, industrial disinfectant, and the tired electricity of overworked computers.
Howard Brennan was secured in a holding cell, his confession to a fifty-year-old murder logged and filed, but the sense of victory was as thin and brittle as old paper. They had caught a ghost from the past, a man whose crimes had seeded the ground for this new harvest of death. But the active, breathing monster who had stalked Tommy Begay through the ruins of Riverside—the one who had collected Samuel Whitehorse’s last words and stolen the final breath from Agnes Littlefeather—was still out there, moving through the deep shadows of the reservation.
Kari stood before the evidence board, which had metastasized from a simple murder investigation into a sprawling, chaotic mural of interconnected tragedies. Photos of Tommy, Samuel, and Agnes stared back at her, their faces a silent triptych of accusation. For four days, they had followed the killer’s meticulously laid trail of breadcrumbs, reacting to each new horror, but they were no closer to his tangible identity than they had been at the start. David Clah remained a phantom, a name tied to rage and rumor, a man who had successfully erased himself for fifteen years.
"We’re one step behind," she said, the words tasting like ash in her mouth. She took a sip of the Americano Ben had placed beside her half an hour ago. The coffee was strong and black, a taste she associated with long nights and stubborn cases. "He wanted us to find Whitehorse. He wanted us to find Agnes. He’s choreographing this whole damn thing, Ben. He’s not just killing people; he’s telling a story, and we’re his unwilling audience."
Ben looked up from a stack of preliminary forensic reports, his face etched with the same bone-deep exhaustion she herself felt. "And he wanted us to catch Brennan," he agreed, his voice low. "He drove him right to us, leaving a trail of psychological terror that a rookie could follow. He was herding him."
"He was isolating him," Kari corrected, a new thought solidifying with chilling clarity. She turned from the board, the sea of faces and red yarn connections swimming in her vision. "That’s his endgame. Taking away Brennan’s freedom, his anonymity, his sense of control. He doesn’t just want Brennan dead. He wants him broken first. He wants him to know, with absolute certainty, that it’s coming."
Her eyes met Ben’s. "Brennan said the person leaving him ‘gifts’ walked off toward the hiking trail behind his neighborhood. The Windy Ridge Trail."
"Leads to the old forest service fire tower," Ben said, his mind already following hers. He straightened. "It’s been abandoned for thirty years, since they switched to aerial surveillance. Nobody goes up there."
"Exactly," Kari said, her voice gaining intensity. It was more than a hunch now; it felt like a certainty, settling in her gut with a familiar, undeniable weight. Her grandmother called it her níłchʼi diyiní—the wind that whispers truth. "It’s isolated. It has a perfect vantage point of the entire valley, including Brennan’s house. If you were going to watch someone, plan something with this level of patience, that’s where you’d do it. A place where the world can’t see you, but you can see the whole world."
Ben rubbed the back of his neck, considering it. "It’s a long shot, Kari. He could have just been heading into the woods to disappear. We should be focusing on tracking David Clah’s last known associates."
"We have no last known associates," she countered, her frustration sharpening her tone. "We have ghosts and fifteen-year-old memories. The killer who staged Tommy’s murder, who researched his victims for months, who picked a professional lock on Agnes’s door, doesn’t do things randomly. That trail was a choice. A deliberate move. Maybe even a mistake, the only one he’s made. Let’s get ahead of him for once, Ben. Let’s stop reacting and start hunting."
Ben studied her for a long moment, his gaze analytical. His trust in her instincts had taken months to build but was now as solid as the sandstone formations outside. He saw the fire in her eyes, the same focused intensity that had cleared so many cases in Phoenix, the same quality her father had once called obsessive and her grandmother called a gift.
Finally, he gave a slow, weary nod.
"Alright," he said. "We hunt. But we go in tactical. If he’s using that tower as a base, he might have set traps. He’s proven he’s careful."
"Then we'll be careful, too," Kari said.
The drive to the Windy Ridge trailhead was quiet, the sky shifting from the deep indigo of late night to the bruised purple of impending dawn. Kari pushed the blue Jeep hard along the winding, empty roads, the landscape a stark silhouette against the emerging light.
This was the part of the job that gnawed at her—the race against the clock, knowing that every minute they spent chasing leads was a minute the killer could be preparing their next move. The land around them was beautiful and unforgiving, a place that held memories older than any human crime. Her mother had written about that, about how the land remembered every violation.
This killer seemed to believe the same thing.
They parked at the trailhead, a small, gravel pull-off being reclaimed by snakeweed and chamisa. The air was thin and bitingly cold, scented with high-desert pine and the clean smell of dust. A faded wooden sign, its letters bleached by decades of sun, announced the trail’s name. It looked forgotten, a path into a part of the past that no one visited anymore. It felt appropriate.
"Two miles to the tower," Ben said, checking the ammunition in his Glock 19. "Steep grade all the way."
"Good," Kari said, braiding her hair into a single, tight plait down her back. "The exercise will clear my head."
They moved out, their boots crunching on the eroded trail. The ascent was grueling, a relentless climb that quickly forced their breathing into a ragged but steady rhythm. They moved in silence, their senses on high alert, scanning the juniper trees and sandstone outcroppings for any sign of movement, any wire or disturbed earth that might signal a trap.
This was the killer’s territory; they were intruders here. The rising sun cast long, distorted shadows that played tricks on the eyes. A raven’s call from a high branch made them both flinch.
Half an hour into the hike, moving through a narrow wash where the ground was still damp from a recent rain, Kari stopped dead. She held up a hand, and Ben froze behind her. There, pressed into the dark red earth, was a single, perfect boot print. It was a man’s, size nine, the tread worn on the outside of the left heel in a distinctive pattern.
"It’s him," she said, her voice a low whisper. She knelt, examining it without touching. "The same print from the Begay scene. He’s been here, and recently. The edges are still sharp."
The tension, already a live wire between them, ratcheted higher. They drew their weapons, the soft snick of safeties being disengaged the only sound in the canyon. They moved more slowly now, using the thick stands of pinyon and the hulking rock formations for cover. The world had narrowed to the twenty feet of trail in front of them, to the sound of their own breathing.
The fire tower appeared through the trees abruptly, a skeletal finger of rusted steel and weathered wood pointing at the morning sky. It stood on the highest point of the ridge, a lonely sentinel that had long ago given up its watch. The small ranger cabin at its base had boarded-up windows, but the door, painted a faded forest-service green, hung slightly ajar, a dark, vertical slash of invitation.
They approached from two sides, weaving through the trees, using the hand signals they had perfected over the past year. Cover me. Moving up. Hold. At the door, Kari paused, pressing her back against the rough wood siding, listening. There was no sound from within but the mournful whisper of wind through broken glass panes high in the tower.
With a final, questioning glance at Ben, who nodded in response, she pivoted, pushing the door fully open and sweeping into the room, weapon leading.
The smell hit her first—stale air, the faint, lingering aroma of woodsmoke from a small, pot-bellied stove in the corner, and the sharp, almost acrid herbal scent of devil’s claw. Maps covered one entire wall, with red yarn connecting photographs and locations in a terrifying web that mirrored the one back at their station, only this one was chillingly complete. She saw photos of Tommy Begay’s apartment, Samuel Whitehorse’s house, Agnes Littlefeather’s street—all taken from a distance, evidence of extensive surveillance.
On another wall hung the historical photos stolen from Agnes’s album, pinned alongside modern ones. A picture of a young, arrogant Howard Brennan at Riverside stood next to a recent telephoto shot of his truck parked in his driveway. A faded picture of the Survivors’ Circle was tacked beside a current-day map showing the last known addresses of Marcus Crow Dog and the other surviving members.
"My God," Ben breathed. He moved further into the room, his weapon still held at a low ready. "He’s been planning this for years."
In the center of the room, a large chalkboard rested on an easel. It was covered in that same careful, almost unnaturally neat block lettering from the notes left at the crime scenes. It wasn't a plan; it was a manifesto, a declaration of purpose.
THE LAND REMEMBERS. EVERY DEBT. EVERY SILENCE.
BALANCE IS NOT JUSTICE; IT IS CORRECTION.
THEY DID NOT DIE. THEY WERE ERASED. I WILL WRITE THEM BACK.
Below the words was a grim accounting of the dead from Riverside: Owen Peshlakai. Sarah Clah. Marcus Todacheene. Janet Yazzie. Robert Nez.
And below that, a second list, a litany of vengeance, each name with a bold, final checkmark beside it: Tommy Begay. Check. Samuel Whitehorse. Check. Agnes Littlefeather. Check.
Kari’s eyes scanned the room, cataloging evidence even as the sheer, calculated coldness of the display sent a chill down her spine. On a small, rickety table sat a spool of the same rough, natural-fiber rope used to bind Tommy and Whitehorse. Beside it were a box of chalk and a small burlap bag filled with dried devil’s claw.
She picked up a piece of the herb; its sharp thorns pricked her glove. The ME’s report flashed in her mind: a folk remedy for joint pain. The limp. The worn-down heel. It all connected.
A rumpled sleeping bag lay in the corner next to a stack of canned food, military-style MREs, and several gallon jugs of water. This wasn’t just a planning room; it was a base of operations, a hermit’s cell. The killer had been living here, sleeping among the ghosts he was avenging, fueling his rage with their stories.
Then she saw it, spread out on the main table under the weak light from a dusty window. A detailed topographical map of the reservation, the kind used by surveyors and serious hikers. The Desert View Motel in Chinle was circled in red ink. An arrow, drawn with a ruler, pointed from it to another, far more remote location deep in the Chuska Mountains, a place known for its treacherous canyons and ancient, undisturbed ruins. The spot was labeled in the same block lettering: "THE FINAL BALANCE."
"He was watching us," Kari said, her voice a low growl of frustration and dawning horror. "He knew we’d find Brennan. He was waiting for it. He wanted us to make the first move."
"He’s taking him somewhere," Ben said, pointing to the second location on the map. "For a grand finale. A ritual."
They were no longer one step behind; they were an integral part of the killer’s script. They had captured Brennan, and in doing so, had set the final, terrible act in motion. As Kari reached for her radio to report their findings, her personal cell phone buzzed, the trill deafening in the charged silence of the room. It was Lisa Becenti.
"Kari, you need to hear this." Lisa’s voice was strained. "We finally broke the encryption on the data recovered from Samuel Whitehorse’s phone. The killer took it after murdering him, but not before Whitehorse uploaded a single file to a secure cloud server. His lawyer just contacted us. It was a dead man’s switch—if Whitehorse didn’t log into the account for forty-eight hours, an email with the link would be automatically sent."
"What was it, Lisa?" Kari asked, her gaze fixed on the chalkboard of the dead, on the name of the final, intended victim still unchecked.
"A video, Kari. Recorded just moments before he died. The killer… he made him confess."
Lisa played the audio over the phone. Samuel Whitehorse’s voice, raspy with terror and the weight of a lifetime of guilt, filled the small, obsessive cabin.
"My name is Samuel Whitehorse… I was chief of security at Riverside Indian Boarding School… Howard Brennan gave the order. He… he killed the boy, Owen Peshlakai. Beat him in the punishment room… I helped. I helped carry his body out to the desert… made it look like coyotes… We all knew. Michael Martinez, Dr. Loomis… we all kept silent. We buried the truth to save ourselves… I’m sorry. To the boy… to his mother… I’m so sorry…"
_preview.jpg)
