Mary Sue Murphy puts her life on hold at the height of her career to take care of her estranged mother suffering from dementia, who believes herself to be the fictional Miss Marple. Now referred to as nephew Raymond, and a whole town playing along, she finds herself mixed up in solving the murder of the dead body her mother found.

In 1867, New York City, William Muldoon is a local wrestling champion and policeman. Muldoon must find the connection between two seemingly unrelated murders and catch the perpetrator before others are killed and his brother is hanged for the crime.

In 1867, New York City, William Muldoon is a local wrestling champion and policeman. Muldoon must find the connection between two seemingly unrelated murders and catch the perpetrator before others are killed and his brother is hanged for the crime.