Jenna found adjusting to married life excruciatingly painful, especially when her new husband did not believe her that their elderly neighbor was deliberately goading her and doing her very best to make her look bad in her husband’s eyes! Will cannot believe that his wife, usually so reasonable, would accuse an eighty-five year old woman of deliberately trying to cause trouble in their marriage! Mrs. Pratt had been his neighbor for years and the fact he needed to defend her from his own wife was embarrassing. He decides it is time to stop threatening to spank his lovely wife, and that it's time to actually do it, much to Jenna’s disbelief! Of course, Jenna can’t help but compare herself to her husband’s first wife and find herself lacking, and she wonders if she will ever be able to make her marriage work, especially when Mrs. Pratt continues to wreak havoc in her marriage… and Will continues to punish Jenna for being upset and angry with the woman!

April has a boss who needs to be taken down a few notches, and she sets out to plan an April Fool's Day prank that would long be remembered. April took great pains to plan everything in great detail, even to hiring a videographer to record the entire program, with the prank against Penelope Winslow as the highlight. Everything goes off without a hitch, only, to her horror, the prank snowballs and the humor is quickly lost in the small town. Especially devastated is Penelope, who refuses to leave her house and cries constantly over her ruined reputation. April feels bad, and is horrified that the prank took off in a way she never anticipated! But she refuses to admit it to anyone else, even when Derrick Winslow, Penelope's handsome nephew comes around asking questions. Derrick has never seen his Aunt Penny so upset, and when he finds the person, or persons, responsible, he intends to see them pay. When he learns that the sweet little redhead his Aunty Penny thought he should meet and fall in love with is the guilty party, he decides that a time-honored way of dealing with little brats will work just fine!